Black Friday and Cyber Monday sale laws: What small businesses need to know
Two of the biggest sale days of the year are coming up. Black Friday is Nov. 27, and Cyber Monday is Nov. 30. These holiday sales bring "was/now" prices, doorbusters, and limited-time offers, and deceptive pricing laws apply to all of them.
Here's the basic rule: The FTC’s Guides Against Deceptive Pricing say you can only compare to a "former price" if you actually offered the item to the public at that price, openly and regularly, for a reasonable amount of time. Otherwise the "bargain" is made up, and so is the discount.
Rocket Lawyer discusses the pricing rules that apply to these sales and offers tips to help small businesses stay compliant.
Rules for advertising a discount
If you advertise a discount from your own former price, be ready to show that price was real. That means it must be a price you offered regularly, not a price you had for one week. For example, bumping up an item's price by $40 in early November so you can advertise it as “35% off” during Black Friday or Cyber Monday is exactly the kind of fake markdown the FTC warns about.
Some states are stricter and spell out exactly how long a price must stay in place, so be sure to check your state's rules.
The same idea applies when you compare your price to someone else's. A "compare at" or list price should be close to what shoppers in your area actually pay for that product, not a sticker price nobody charges. And with a "buy one, get one" deal, tell people the catch up front. If the free item must be the same size or the deal ends Sunday, say so in the ad.
The FTC’s guides say all the terms should be clear from the start.
What can go wrong during holiday sales?
Three main problems often come up during holiday sales:
- A wrong price. Whether you must honor an advertised price mistake depends on your state, your terms of sale, and when you accepted the order. For that reason, many online stores include a provision in their terms saying an order isn't accepted until it ships. If your terms do have such a line item, that $200 jacket that accidentally went live at $20 may be canceled. An even easier suggestion: Have someone else double-check prices before anything goes out.
- Running out of a doorbuster. The FTC's Guides Against Bait Advertising say you shouldn't advertise a product unless you have enough to meet reasonably expected demand, unless your ad clearly says supply is limited. Adding a simple "limited quantities" or "only 25 in stock" helps set expectations, but it doesn't automatically make a misleading offer acceptable. However, whether you owe shoppers a rain check after you sell out depends on where you’re located. Some states require one in certain cases, so check your state's rules before the sale.
- Shipping dates. Under the FTC's Mail, Internet, or Telephone Order Merchandise Rule, you need a reasonable basis to believe you can actually ship by then. If you don't give a date, the default is 30 days after receiving the order. When a delay hits, you generally have to let the customer know and give them the choice to wait or get their money back. Before you promise holiday delivery, check with your warehouse or carrier about what’s realistic.
Questions to ask before your sale goes live
- Can I prove the "original" price I'm advertising was a real price? Do I have records showing how long I charged it?
- What if I post the wrong price or sell out of a doorbuster item? Do my terms cover it, and does my state require rain checks?
- Will shoppers see my exclusions and return policy before they buy, or only after?
- Can I actually meet the shipping dates I'm advertising? What will I do if there's a delay?
What to do next
- Review your price history. Check every item you plan to discount, and save records of what you charged and when.
- Spell out your terms. Put sale exclusions, limits, and your return policy in plain language, close to the offer.
- Match your ads to your stock and shipping. Set quantity limits, say so in the ad, and don't promise dates you can't meet.
- Update your terms of sale. Cover price errors, rain checks, and cancellations.
Start with your price records. They're your best defense if a discount is ever questioned.
This story was produced by Rocket Lawyer and reviewed and distributed by Stacker.






















